I was drawn to this sweater because of the fit and construction and detail. I have a black pleated skirt I will pear it with for the Holidays. The fact that it is great with jeans is a plus. I like the short length. The shoulder pads take some getting used to. I remember those days 30 years ago.....I may remove them for my own comfort but it is a good look...I am a size 8 and bought a M...in hind sight, I should have purchased a S but by the time I tried to exchange the sweater they were sold out......If you want a close fit at the waist...the smaller size for me is the better choice, but what I have now , the M will be fine ..I keep checking if a small might become available. This is a very classic sweater and one I will use for a long time